Colgate - Nature's Extracts - Ultimate Fresh - Toothpaste

This green coloured toothpaste is a fantastic alternative to mint flavoured toothpaste.
The lemon and aloe vera flavour in very refreshing and will leave your mouth feeling clean.
It foams up well (in a toothpaste-sense) and doesn't trigger my allergic reaction to toothpaste, so it may be a good option for ypu if you also can't use most toothpastes.

Scent: 5/5
Price: 2/5 ($5.82 for 75mL)
Effectiveness: 5/5

Parodontax - Extra Frisch (Extra Fresh) - Toothpaste

Guys, I think I have a toothpaste I'm not allergic too!!!!!

This is a sodium bicarbonate based toothpaste with a minty touch.
It does taste salty with a touch of mint, but I'll take it!

The colour is coral, which is adorable.
It has fluoride, which I look for in a toothpaste. Don't @ me fluorophobes! 

Not really what I meant...

I'm so happy and I love it! 
I also love the price! (I was used to paying a lot more for tooth mousse.)

Price: 5/5 ($6.10 for 75mL)
Scent: 5/5 (minty)
Effectiveness: 5/5

GC Tooth Mousse Plus

Starting when I was ~15 years old, my lips began to crack and peel and bleed. I had to cover them in Vaseline constantly to prevent pain and further damage. Fast forward to two years ago when I went to a (unfortunately rude) skin specialist who suggested I may be allergic to toothpaste.
I stopped using the minty staple and my lips repaired... I am allergic to toothpaste.

But if I can't use toothpaste, what can I use on my tooty-pegs?

The answer is GC Tooth Mousse Plus

It comes in flavours like vanilla, strawberry, melon, tutti-frutti, and mint (I avoid this last one).
It is activated by saliva and is full of lovely fluoride (don't even bother sending me your 'fluoride is the devil' conspiracy nonsense).

 The only drawback is it is very expensive (~$30 for 40g) but I have no other choice :(

Price: 1/5 ($21.95 for 40g)
Scent: 3.5/5
Effectiveness: 5/5