Alterra Naturkosmetik - Kajal Eyeliner - 01 Black

This is a vegan, natural eyeliner pencil.
It is also suitable for people who use contact lenses.

It is quite soft, which I don't hate.

The colour payoff is really nice!

Eye liner on the outer half of the top lid and with mascara on the top lashes.

Price: 5/5 ($2.80 for one pencil)
Effectiveness: 5/5

Same Product, Different Colour - Physicians Formula - Shimmer Strips - Kohl Kajal Eyeliner Trio - Green Eyes - Green

This is the green version of the black and purple kohl tried earlier.


It's quite nice! Easy to apply and good colour pay off. 

It is only the black in this trio that fails.


***** This product could be reviewed thanks to the raunchy, informative and gorgeous Miss Smut Buttons! *****

Same Product, Different Colour - Bianca J Professional - Eye Liner - BJEL37

This is a lovely green coloured eye liner.

It is a little hard, but not impossible, and it has a good colour payoff.

***** This product could be reviewed thanks to the raunchy, informative and gorgeous Miss Smut Buttons! *****

Physicians Formula - Shimmer Strips - Kohl Kajal Eyeliner Trio - Green Eyes - Black

I'm disappointed in the colour payoff from this.

The colour is quite weak.

It is soft enough but has little flecks of green glitter in it which make it gritty as well.

One pass.
I'm not going to do multiple passes on my eye with this to build up the coverage.

Price: 4/5 ($11.95 for 3)
Scent: 2.5/5 (no scent)
Effectiveness: 3/5

***** This product could be reviewed thanks to the raunchy, informative and gorgeous Miss Smut Buttons! *****

Eye of Horus - Goddess Pencil - Selenite White

I purchased this to be a waterline pencil, but it is too hard :(
It would damage my eyelid to use it like this.

So I have resigned to using it as a highlighter (yes, I'm that pale that only pure white can actually be a highlight on me).
It does give a good colour payoff, but I just can't use it.
I have heard of softening eyeliner pencils with a lighter, but I'm not putting something that is heated with a lighter near my eye.

I'm certain that the onyx version of this pencil was softer.
I think it is just the formula of this shade.
For the price though, I am disappointed.

Price: 2/5 ($30 for one pencil)
Effectiveness: 1/5

Rimmel - Scandaleyes - Waterproof Micro Eyeliner

I really wanted this to work!

It is something about my skin, my face produces so much oil (which isn't always bad). It is because of this natural oil that this felt-tip liner won't work on me.

The minute I try to line my eyes, it just stops working. The oils preventing the wicking action that the marker-like eye liner works by.

On my hand, this works fine. Moderate colour intensity, good line control.

Please, Rimmel, make a felt-tip liner that works for me!

Price: 1.5/5 (RRP $12.95 for 1.1mL)
Scent: 2.5/5 (none)
Effectiveness: 0/5 (on me)