Avon - Tropical Paradise - Kohl Eye Liner - Cobalt Blue

This is a bright blue eyeliner that has a really nice colour payoff.

It also isn't too hard :)

Price: **No longer sold
Scent: 2.5/5 (pencil smell)
Effectiveness: 5/5

The Body Shop - Crayon Kohl - Eye Definer - Black

This black eye liner really disappointed me! :C

As is, it barely transfers at all:

It works when you pass it over a flame:

But I shouldn't have to heat it up like a drug fiend.

Really disappointed in you, Body Shop! You are usually amazing.

Price: 3/5 ($16)
Scent: 2.5/5 (pencil smell)
Effectiveness: 0.5/5

L'Oreal Paris - HIP Kohl Eyeliner - Teal Kohl

I love the packaging of this!
It is sleek, easy to use, and allows precision.

The colour payoff is great! 
It is a beautiful dark teal color.
Although it almost seems gritty.

It doesn't stay in place very well though, it kept coming off onto my eyelids.

Price: 3/5 (~$6 for 1.2g)
Scent: 2.5/5 (Why does it smell like pencils?!)
Effectiveness: 4/5

***** This product could be reviewed thanks to the raunchy, informative and gorgeous Miss Smut Buttons! *****